Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Majors in higher education

There are a handful of colleges in the US that subscribe to a type of Classical or liberal arts education that doesn't allow students to select majors. Instead, the whole curriculum is composed of a broad range range of subjects over the entire four years. I once looked at one when I was doing the college-search thing: Shimer College, in the Chicago area. Ultimately, I decided no because I wanted to study math, and you couldn't really go to grad school in math after a general education like that, without calculus and the entire selection of normal upper level math classes. It'd just be impossible (I must've been thinking seriously enough about grad school at that point... funny).

My reasoning for such a decision now is not quite along the same lines, but related. The question I'd consider now is: is specialization really so bad, and is such a broad curriculum for undergraduate study really a good idea? Yes, that's really two questions in one, but my thoughts on each flow into each other.

I'm inclined to say no to both.


First, specialization, in the sense mentioned above. I won't address specialization like graphic design or forestry, et cetera--save it for a different time and place. I mean specialization as in history, English, mathematics, chemistry. I think there are some benefits to majors that you can't get from four year's broad study of various subjects.

A major trains you in a specific discipline, teaching you how to think as a mathematician, economist, biologist, et cetera. These are distinct ways of thinking. Connected, and at times overlapping, yes. But distinct. There is enough distinction between many of these disciplines that they are worth studying on their own, without worrying overmuch about the other disciplines except as necessary.

For example: math, chemistry, biology, and physics. They all overlap, but each can and should be studied on its own. Pure math, which really gets to the heart of mathematics, can't be done without distinctly mathematical thinking: logical, deductive reasoning from premises or axioms you know or hold to be true. Math is related to the sciences, but the sciences use inductive reasoning. You can't use inductive reasoning in math. You end up with false conclusions. Also, try the scientific method with math. Doesn't really work. Math is related, but distinct from the sciences--to do mathematics you need to be trained in mathematical thinking. Not scientific or philosophical, but mathematical thinking. To really do justice to it, you really need to study mathematics in its own context.


To do this, you need time. Mathematics in particular is not something that can be rushed. You need to be able to handle the rigor of something like calculus (the kind that is usually taught after pre-calc or trig) before you can write proofs. It's not that proofs require calculus--over my undergraduate career I rarely had a class where you needed to be able to compute things from calculus. But it's typically required for beginning undergraduates because the level of thinking in calc prepares them for the real work ahead, the logic of proof-solving. One needs time to build up the thinking skills that linear algebra (a common class after calc) starts you on, before you jump into Real Analysis (hardest undergraduate class I took, entirely proofs-based, and hours-long proofs). That takes time. Undergraduate math curriculums push students hard--that's over several years, at least. And it's not till the latter part of those several years do you really catch on to thinking mathematically. Once you do catch on, doing it more teaches you proficiency and allows you the time to learn the skill and art of it.

I think during spring semester this year was when I really started to be able to think as a historian. I took a total of five history classes, two of them at an introductory level, the other three 400 or 500-level courses. It wasn't till the last that I really caught on to thinking that way, and largely because of taking History and Philosophy of History the previous semester, not because I figured it out along the way as most majors have to do.


It does take time to pick up these distinct ways of thinking. I think it's valuable to do so. Studying a discipline itself gives one a greater depth of understanding to that discipline. I'm not sure if you can really train that in a college curriculum without majors. Sure, you'll have an understanding of a broad range of subjects--if you're an advocate of the liberal arts, that's good, right? But you'll also miss a depth of understanding that you gain from concentrated study in one area. Even graduating with a mathematics major, I'm still aware of a depth of my subject that I couldn't reach simply with an undergraduate degree. There'd be a special kind of pleasure in being able to pursue that further. As a friend once said to me, majors provide the satisfaction of depth that breadth doesn't satisfy. Maybe that's a flaw of our liberal arts curriculums? Maybe not.


Thinking about specific, extant, colleges that run on a "no major" curriculum, I do have this thought, though: what they might be able to do is teach students how to think in many of the humanities disciplines. Especially English, history, and philosophy, which they tend to weigh heavily (though history a little less so?). So perhaps it's possible to teach students how to think in several different disciplines. It's impossible to do that with everything. There's just not enough time over four years and 124 credits or however many a college requires for their degrees. I would note that math and the sciences are sadly neglected at these schools, except perhaps in a philosophical treatment. Granted, I wouldn't mind seeing more philosophical (and historical) treatment in traditional math and the science departments, but this still doesn't get to the actual things themselves. It's teaching about the disciplines and not the disciplines themselves.


So, are colleges with four-year liberal arts programs better than liberal arts colleges with a solid core curriculum and majors? I don't know that they are. I do think majors teach a lot of good things that a broad 4-year curriculum can't. And then to speak practically, broad liberal arts degrees can work well for people interested in them and who say, want to go on to grad school in the humanities, if the student has a good grasp of the specific discipline already. But jobs? Eh. For some jobs that want to see you have some sort of college degree, sure. For some jobs that traditionally like econ, poli sci, et cetera, maybe--if the student has taken an independent interest in them outside of schoolwork (in all the free time that they have). For others, no. Science and math, other technical fields certainly not. Those fields kind of get shortchanged here.

I think you can construct a Classical/liberal arts college curriculum without making it the whole of the four years. I happen to think my alma mater (alma mater... weird) has done a fairly good job of this. Could it be better? Sure. Does it do what a liberal arts education sets out to do? If you think it means making students conversant across different disciplines, giving them some appreciation and understanding of them, I'd say by and large that it does. Stronger with some disciplines and weaker in others, but yes, it does. I don't think 4-year liberal arts programs are necessary. I wouldn't say they shouldn't exist--I'm inclined to say that at that level of education it might come to personal preference. If you want that, go ahead. But on a practical level, aspiring doctors, scientists, mathematicians... need to look elsewhere.



Notes: now I'm terribly curious, though. I need to find someone who is/was some kind of interdisciplinary major at Hillsdale about what they think about training in specific disciplines. Also, a question that follows from the above: if majors, some amount of "specialization" can be good, how far do we take majors? As mentioned above, are graphic design and forestry good majors for us to have, for 4-year universities and colleges? Things to philosophize about later...

1 comment:

Abigail said...

I agree. Hillsdale's longevity and success come from its unique combination of a liberal arts worldview for a particular major. Very few other schools offer the ability to study a breadth of subjects while relating them all to the same depth of a particular major. As an English major, my views of "Absalom, Absalom!" by William Faulkner were influenced by my knowledge of history (setting, dialogue), psychology (understanding character growth, language, behavior), grammar (or sometimes lack thereof), theology/philosophy, and various portions of math/science as they're applicable. Without such a training, I wouldn't have gleaned the same joy and satisfaction from Faulkner as I did.

On another note: Don't forget that for years and years, there was no such thing as a "liberal arts" education. People grew up in (get this) trade schools. Today, trade schools are disparaged as lower-class options for more unintelligent yet still aspiring members of society. I feel like this is bull. Higher education does the same thing that a trade school does with different mediums: the music major is trained in the field, practice, and science of music just as the metallurgist is trained to forge and work with metal. They're skills. Good liberal arts schools remember this fact as they create their curriculum; they recognize that their students graduate not with simply knowledge, but with marketable skills and training in a specific area. If a school doesn't do this, then I don't think it's quite done its job. I think you understand what I'm saying.

Well-written article, deary. I was glad to read your thoughts. Keep writing! and good luck!

-Abby Newman