I recently noted in ethics that the common perception of power is that of a very visible position, the person you see at the very forefront of things. Yes, that is power, and it has the added pressure of being so visible.
The connection here, of course, is gender ethics, the assertion of contemporary society that staying at home, running a house and raising children rather than being out in the workplace is oppressive towards women.
In a way, yes, it does seem sensible that staying home and raising children is oppressive. You're out there in the business world, and by golly, with your skills and talent you're going to climb the ladder and make a name for yourself, and you will thus be admired and respected. But again, this assumes that power is something that will be visible.
Is staying at home and raising children a position of weakness? True, were the husband the breadwinner and were the parents to divorce, he would have a job and she wouldn't, and often mothers are given custody of children. See my prior comment upon having a stay-at-home parent. If it is indeed better that there be a parent at home, how are you going to choose? Say it is oppressive that a parent stay home and raise children: how do we decide who will stay home? Either way, someone will be oppressed, and you cannot say that we should exchange one extreme for another. This would be blatantly unfair. So within that framework, how does one balance the issues of oppression and the well-being of children?
But back to the matter of power. I find the denial of influence of a stay-at-home mom on children would be somewhat akin to denying that a teacher can have significant influence upon you. The difference is that a parent is a primary teacher for the first eighteen years of a child's life, not just a semester or even a year. That, and given eighteen years the influence in inevitable. And that job as a teacher (and caretaker) is full-time. Ask women who raise or have raised children. To say that doing so in a "full-time" capacity is oppression is to assert that it lacks a dignity or honor, and therefore deny the importance of that influence. (side note: I was tempted to say that such a denial is to say that it is not hard work, but doing such work may be hard while not being dignified work)
Cliche it might be, but it rings true that such people do great work in shaping the next generation, and the next generation will shape our world and determine the direction of society.
Such disparaging of stay-at-home parents only dismisses the weight of influence, but also places children at a lower value. The claim says that their education and upbringing are of lesser importance: your own career is more important. I will say that yes, it is necessary to bring in a paycheck, but we cannot discount other matters in life.
There are a few more thoughts on power swirling in the mind, but I'll cap it here and leave the rest for another time.
Friday, April 24, 2009
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
Oppression of women, part 1
The topic of gender roles has arisen in Ethics, and much of the time was devoted to lively debate on the oppression of women. The following were sparked by that debate.
First thought: Barring the rarity of parents who are truly psychopathic, I suspect that people would generally agree that it is best when children can be raised by their parents, rather than by a stranger. It seems that there is something intrinsically good in strong parent-child relationships, and when the parents are able to teach their kids. It strengthens the family unit, kids are happier. And that's something that logistically can't happen if both parents work full time, because the kids come home between two or three in the afternoon to a babysitter or empty house, and perhaps the parents won't be home till five or so, and by then both parents are tired and have less energy to spend on their kids.
Second thought: aside from teenagers in rebellion mode, do people who had a stay-at-home parent ever say that they wished that parent had been working instead? I don't think I've ever met anyone who didn't love having a parent at home, though it is of course possible that this is my limited experience. It might be worth noting that I've even found this true of families who have low incomes as a result. It does mean more scrimping and saving, but I don't know if I've ever knew a such a kid to wish that both his or her parents worked so their family could live more easily.
Third thought: if women staying at home, managing house, raising kids while their husbands are the primary breadwinners is oppression against them, is it oppression against men for those roles to be reversed? It must be, it seems, and I cannot see how such oppression against men may be fair. In the case that society is badly imbalanced in this treatment of men and women, how can the replacement of one extreme with the opposite be any good? I have difficulty in accepting that it is good to trade one extreme with the other.
Fourth thought: If we can agree that if financially possible, it is best to have a parent who is at home (or at least only works part-time in order to take care of the kids), we must ask who should stay home with the kids. The husband or wife? One way or another, someone should to do it. Someone has to, and consequently someone must be the primary breadwinner. In this case, how is it oppression to be the stay-at-home parent? And why isn't this a good thing? Is it somehow bad to act for the well-being of your kids?
Hopefully there'll be more time and more thoughts to continue on this topic in the near future.
First thought: Barring the rarity of parents who are truly psychopathic, I suspect that people would generally agree that it is best when children can be raised by their parents, rather than by a stranger. It seems that there is something intrinsically good in strong parent-child relationships, and when the parents are able to teach their kids. It strengthens the family unit, kids are happier. And that's something that logistically can't happen if both parents work full time, because the kids come home between two or three in the afternoon to a babysitter or empty house, and perhaps the parents won't be home till five or so, and by then both parents are tired and have less energy to spend on their kids.
Second thought: aside from teenagers in rebellion mode, do people who had a stay-at-home parent ever say that they wished that parent had been working instead? I don't think I've ever met anyone who didn't love having a parent at home, though it is of course possible that this is my limited experience. It might be worth noting that I've even found this true of families who have low incomes as a result. It does mean more scrimping and saving, but I don't know if I've ever knew a such a kid to wish that both his or her parents worked so their family could live more easily.
Third thought: if women staying at home, managing house, raising kids while their husbands are the primary breadwinners is oppression against them, is it oppression against men for those roles to be reversed? It must be, it seems, and I cannot see how such oppression against men may be fair. In the case that society is badly imbalanced in this treatment of men and women, how can the replacement of one extreme with the opposite be any good? I have difficulty in accepting that it is good to trade one extreme with the other.
Fourth thought: If we can agree that if financially possible, it is best to have a parent who is at home (or at least only works part-time in order to take care of the kids), we must ask who should stay home with the kids. The husband or wife? One way or another, someone should to do it. Someone has to, and consequently someone must be the primary breadwinner. In this case, how is it oppression to be the stay-at-home parent? And why isn't this a good thing? Is it somehow bad to act for the well-being of your kids?
Hopefully there'll be more time and more thoughts to continue on this topic in the near future.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)