Sunday, January 31, 2010

On filtering

Some post-conversation thoughts from today.

The topic was orthodox Christian teaching at an officially secular school. It was brought up that one must run the class content through a filter when the content discusses matters of Christian belief and theology. This was true of my former school. This is true of Hillsdale, even if most of us feel that there's much we don't need to filter. For the orthodox Christian, much good can be gained from such classes in a secular school (some secular schools, anyway), but it's always necessary to filter the content through what we understand as biblical.

What I remembered later is that this is true even at a Christian school, and even in other subjects. What you have found to be correct theology likely differs from your professors. The more familiar you are with theology and its nuances the more you will see this to be true, and the more you will be able to filter.

Except for math and the hard sciences which are fairly impervious to bias (yes, this could be a bit over-simplifying), one shouldn't blindly accept ideas or interpretations. This may be as simple as determining whether something seems right given what you do know, and this is often what happens at the lower undergraduate levels. Simply put, at that point we typically don't know enough to be more discerning, though this skill develops as we continue in our education, and as we grow older and learn more we develop the background and the mind to be more discerning.

Without a more thorough background, it's hard to contrast competing ideas and weigh their respective merits, but filtering can be as simple as considering whether the interpretation seems plausible to you. At a deeper level, it can involve a very conscious and very involved process of picking out the good from the bad.


So there's a fragment (or fragments?) for you. To sleep with me; this week I'm going to try minimizing last week's late nights and subsequent early mornings.

No comments: